Men’s fear: she’s a poser

Talking about dating with a midlife single friend he asked, “Do you know men’s biggest dating fear?”

“Dating a psycho?”


“Getting an STD?”


“She gets pregnant?”

“Those are all high on the list, but it’s not what I’m thinking of.”

“Well, many women’s fear is abandonment, but I doubt that’s men’s fear.”

“It’s not.”

“What then?”

“That the woman he’s falling for is a poser.”

“You mean that she pretends to be someone she’s not?”

“Sort of. When you’re dating, a woman says she loves to watch sports. So you snuggle up together to watch football, basketball, whatever. She’s right next to her man while reviewing the ESPN highlights. You take her to live games. Or she says she loves your favorite kind of food, your friends, your mother. But then, when you’re thinking ‘This has to be the most amazing woman on the planet,’ and you fall head over heels for her, things start to change.”

“Like what?”

“You discover she’s just been pretending. She’s really not into sports, your friends, family or food. She’s just been going along with you thinking it will make you like her more. By the time you discover it, you’ve moved in together and now extricating yourself is very difficult.”

“And you feel duped.”

“Exactly. So now I know to hang out longer before making the plunge. See how she is over time, after the trying-to-impress-you phase lapses.”

While this man felt that this behavior was prevalent in women, I can see it happens in both genders. I’ve had men suggest movies that later I learned they loathed, but they knew I wanted to see. I think it’s our wanting to make a positive impression so we’re flexible and amenable to doing what they want. The challenge is when that impression is seared into their thinking that’s how you always are or what you like.

For example, I rarely drink. I may have one drink a month, and then only socially, often on a date. I’m not a teetotaler; I just know I have low tolerance so I don’t regularly imbibe.

A man I dated for months brought me a gift of a bottle of port. Knowing he liked to have a glass in the evening, I’d bring it out when he was over and join him. After a few months of this behavior, he sat me down and said, “I’m concerned that you always seem to need a drink when I’m around. I’m hoping you can enjoy my company without needing alcohol to loosen up.”

I was shocked. I was only having a glass to join him. I didn’t “need” alcohol to be comfortable. He’d formed an opinion on why I did something based on only his limited observation — which is what nearly all of us do. I was grateful he brought it up so I could share my perspective.

Was I being a poser? In a way, yes. Since I rarely drink, I was “posing” as someone who drank regularly because I had a glass of port when he was around. Did I do it to make him like me more? Perhaps. I did it to share an activity I knew he liked, just like I agreed to accompany him to exotic restaurants, even though they wouldn’t have been my choice. And he went to foreign films because he knew I enjoyed them, even though he wouldn’t have chosen them on his own.

So where’s the line between pretending to like something and agreeing to participate in something you know the other likes? I think you need to verbalize what’s going on: “I wouldn’t normally choose an Ethiopian restaurant, but I know you love the cuisine so I’d like to try it with you.” “Spending Sunday watching football is not how I typically spend the day, but I want to be with you so will watch it with you today.”

I think you have to strike a balance between only doing what you want and a willingness to try what your honey likes. If it is odious to you, share that you know he likes it, but you’d rather find things that you both enjoy. Or compromise like snuggling on the couch during the game, but you read with earphones playing music you like.

Where do you think is the line between pretending to like something you don’t really, therefore being a poser, and wanting do be agreeable about joining your sweetie in activities you know he likes and you only tolerate?


Embracing Midlife MenWant more information on undersdtanding men over 40? Download the eBook Embracing Midlife Men: Insights Into Curious Behaviors to start reading more immediately.


5 responses to “Men’s fear: she’s a poser”

  1. Jack Avatar

    I’ve made this mistake enough to learn to be up front about personal preferences. I don’t drink but its okay if they do. I like foreign films but I also laughed my head off at Talledega Nights. This approach removes some of the mystery and game playing of course. Bear in mind also that I spent Valentines Day alone eating high fiber cereal and watching the LPGA. Hmmm…maybe a new approach is called for… “Oh I’d love to see Marly and Me” or watch Sex in the City reruns…” Nah…I’ll stick with my approach for a while longer.

  2. rkintn Avatar

    That explains alot. I have a variety of interests and I’m pretty easygoing when it comes to trying new things. But, while there may be alot of activities I’ve done before I may not be currently pursuing them alone, but would be more than happy to pursue them as a couple. For instance, I like to hunt and fish, but being a single mom, I don’t have alot of time to pursue them on my own but I would be very happy to pursue them with a man who liked to hunt and fish. Does that make me a poser? I don’t think so, but now I am beginning to thing the guys may think so.

    Thanks for the insight:)

  3. Grateful Avatar

    Brilliant suggestions! I hadn’t thought of using the “I wouldn’t normally choose…but I will try it because you want to do it.” Who knows if the other person wasn’t posing too, thinking their choice would make them look “cool” or please you? This frees up both of you to be yourselves and honor the other person. It also helps refocus a self-centered “other” make a choice for the relationship and you rather than just meeting their own needs. Thanks DG! Can’t wait to try it.

  4. Mitsy Avatar

    I can’t say that I’ve been guilty of this. I’m honest about not being into sports or hunting or fishing. I do the same when it comes to other topics. I don’t pretend to be someone I’m not. But even being honest and upfront about our likes & dislikes doesn’t mean the guy isn’t “pretending” to be into you when he’s not. I’m sure there are some women who play these kinds of games, but most I know would not lie to a guy about such common interests in order to “snag” him. I think most women are not that desperate.

  5. Lola/ Avatar

    I think the best thing to do is to convey that this is who I am warts and all and what would impress me the most would be for you to be yourself also. So we both can make an informed decision about where we might want to go with the realtionship.